Kennedy v. Bremerton (2022)
Background Information
Understanding the facts and constitutional questions
🔗 Connecting to Our Guiding Question
When, if ever, should the government be allowed to limit a person's constitutional rights in order to protect the community?
This case asks: Should schools be able to limit a public employee's First Amendment free exercise rights (by restricting prayer) to protect the school community from religious coercion and maintain separation of church and state? Consider how this case balances individual religious freedom against the community's interest in preventing government endorsement of religion.
Key People in This Case
An assistant coach who prayed at the 50-yard line after games. After the school told him to stop, he refused and was not rehired. He argued the school violated his religious freedom.
Asked Kennedy to pray privately instead of publicly. They worried that a coach praying at school events might seem like the government endorsing religion.
Some players voluntarily joined Kennedy's prayers. Kennedy said participation was never required, but the school worried students might feel pressured to join their coach.
An employee from another school district who noticed the prayer at a game and contacted Bremerton with concerns, triggering the dispute.
What Happened?
Joseph Kennedy was a football coach at Bremerton High School in Washington state. In 2015, after watching a movie about a coach who prayed, Kennedy decided to incorporate prayer into his coaching routine.
After each game, Kennedy would walk to the 50-yard line of the football field, kneel down, and offer a brief, quiet prayer of thanks. Initially, Kennedy prayed alone. However, some players noticed what he was doing and asked if they could join him. Kennedy said yes, but he made it clear that participation was voluntary - he never required or even asked players to pray with him.
Over time, the post-game prayers grew. Players from both teams, other coaches, and sometimes parents and community members would join Kennedy at midfield. This continued for several years without any complaints.
In September 2015, an employee from another school district attended a game and noticed the prayer. This person contacted the Bremerton School District to express concern about a coach leading prayer at a school event.
The school district became worried about potential legal problems. They were concerned that having a coach pray publicly might violate the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment, which prohibits government endorsement of religion.
The district told Kennedy he could continue to pray, but asked him to do so privately. Kennedy refused, believing that praying at midfield was important to his personal faith practice.
On October 16, 2015, Kennedy prayed on the field again after a game. This time, news media showed up, and a large crowd rushed onto the field. The situation became chaotic, and students had to be moved to safety.
After this incident, the school district placed Kennedy on administrative leave and eventually did not renew his contract. Kennedy sued, claiming the school violated his First Amendment rights.
The Big Question
Can a public school coach engage in personal prayer on school property where students and the public can see him? Or does this violate the separation of church and state?
What You Need to Know
The First Amendment has two clauses about religion:
Free Exercise Clause: "Congress shall make no law...prohibiting the free exercise" of religion. This protects people's right to practice their faith.
Establishment Clause: "Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion." This prevents the government from endorsing or favoring any religion.
These two clauses sometimes seem to conflict - protecting religious freedom while preventing government endorsement of religion.
Important Facts
- Kennedy's prayers were brief (15-30 seconds) and quiet
- He initially prayed alone, then others voluntarily joined
- He never required or asked students to participate
- The prayers continued for years without complaints
- The school offered alternatives (praying privately) but Kennedy refused
- The final prayer became a media spectacle with safety concerns
Vocabulary
Argument Sorting Activity
Work with your group to sort these arguments
Instructions: Read each argument below and select which side it helps from the dropdown menu. When you're finished, click "Check Answers" to see your results.
The Two Sides
Coach Kennedy
The First Amendment protects his right to pray privately. He prayed on his own time after games as a personal religious expression, not as part of his official coaching duties.
Bremerton School District
When a coach prays publicly at school events, students may feel pressured to join. The Establishment Clause requires schools to stay neutral on religion and not appear to endorse it.
| Argument | Answer |
|---|---|
| Praying at midfield was an important part of his personal religious practice. Evidence: Kennedy testified that after watching the movie Facing the Giants, he made a commitment to God to pray after every game for 7 years. His prayers lasted only 15-30 seconds and were quiet expressions of gratitude. | |
| Accommodating his prayer practice does not violate the Establishment Clause. Evidence: The Supreme Court ruled 6-3 that the "Establishment Clause" (which says government can't promote religion) does not require the government to be hostile to religion. Letting someone pray privately is different from the school leading prayers. | |
| A reasonable observer would think the school was endorsing Christianity when they saw the coach praying. Evidence: Kennedy prayed at the 50-yard line — the most visible spot on the field — while wearing his Bremerton coaching gear. Photos show him surrounded by players in uniform. A spectator would reasonably think this was a school-sponsored religious activity. | |
| Students might feel pressured to join prayer to stay on the team or please their coach. Evidence: Coaches decide who gets playing time. One parent told the school district their son "felt he had to participate" in the prayers to get playing time. Even without direct pressure, teenagers often feel they must do what authority figures do. | |
| The Free Exercise Clause protects his right to pray according to his faith. Evidence: The First Amendment's "Free Exercise Clause" says the government cannot prohibit people from practicing their religion. The Supreme Court has ruled this protection applies to all Americans — including government employees like teachers and coaches. | |
| Kennedy's refusal to compromise created safety issues when media and crowds rushed the field. Evidence: On October 16, 2015, after Kennedy announced he would pray publicly, media showed up and a crowd rushed onto the field. The school had to move students for their safety. One player was even knocked down in the chaos. | |
| The government cannot force religious people to hide their faith or pray only in private. Evidence: Justice Gorsuch wrote that the Constitution "neither mandates nor permits the government to suppress such religious expression." Requiring Kennedy to pray in a closet or office would treat religious expression as something shameful that must be hidden. | |
| The school offered reasonable alternatives - Kennedy could pray privately in his office. Evidence: The school district offered Kennedy multiple alternatives: praying in his office, praying in the locker room, or praying after students had left. Kennedy could still practice his faith — just not in a way that looked like school endorsement. | |
| Schools have a special responsibility to avoid even the appearance of religious endorsement. Evidence: In Lee v. Weisman (1992), the Court banned school-sponsored graduation prayers. In Santa Fe v. Doe (2000), the Court banned student-led prayers at football games. Schools must be especially careful because students are young and impressionable. | |
| His prayers were personal, brief, and quiet - not attempts to convert students or promote religion. Evidence: Kennedy's prayers lasted only 15-30 seconds. He prayed silently with his head bowed. He never asked students to join, never gave sermons, and never tried to convert anyone. He simply gave personal thanks to God after games. | |
| The Establishment Clause requires schools to remain neutral on religious matters. Evidence: The Establishment Clause (part of the First Amendment) says government "shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion." This means public schools — which are part of the government — cannot favor any religion or appear to promote religious practices. | |
| When a government employee prays publicly, it appears that the government endorses that religion. Evidence: Kennedy was a public school employee being paid with taxpayer money to coach students. When he prayed on the school's field, in school gear, surrounded by students, it looked like the school (a government institution) was endorsing Christianity. | |
| Public employees retain their First Amendment rights even while working. Evidence: The Supreme Court has ruled that government workers don't "shed their constitutional rights" at work. Teachers can wear religious jewelry, coaches can attend church — working for the government doesn't mean giving up all religious expression. | |
| He never required, asked, or pressured students to join his prayers. Evidence: Kennedy testified he never asked any student to pray with him. Students joined on their own. The Supreme Court noted that "learning how to tolerate speech or prayer of all kinds is part of learning how to live in a pluralistic society." |
Key Terms for Arguments
Important concepts to understand when debating this case
Pressure or force that makes someone feel they must participate in religious activity.
When government actions appear to favor or promote religion.
A legal test asking whether a typical person would think the government is endorsing religion.
Evidence Vault
Real sources to build your debate arguments
Complete the Argument Sort to Unlock
Finish the sorting activity above and check your answers to access real case sources.
Analyze the Sources
Read each excerpt carefully. Decide which side of the case it supports — or if it could be used by both sides.
Personal Prayer Time
Personal Prayer Time
Free Exercise and Free Speech Rights
Free Exercise and Free Speech Rights
No Coercion
No Coercion
Seven Years of Practice
Seven Years of Practice
Establishment Clause Violation
Establishment Clause Violation
Coach as Role Model
Coach as Role Model
Student Coercion Concerns
Student Coercion Concerns
Public School Setting
Public School Setting
Connecting to Today
How these constitutional questions still matter
Questions about religious expression in public schools continue to spark debate across the country. Consider these modern situations:
Prayer at Graduation
Communities debate whether prayers or religious messages should be part of graduation ceremonies. Some argue it's a valued tradition; others say it excludes non-religious students.
Think about: Is there a difference between a student leading prayer and a teacher doing so?
Religious Items in Classrooms
Some teachers display religious items or quotes in their classrooms. Schools must decide if this is personal expression or government endorsement of religion.
Think about: Can teachers share their beliefs, or does their position of authority change things?
Student Religious Clubs
Students want to form religious clubs and pray together at school. Schools must balance supporting student expression while not favoring any particular religion.
Think about: Should schools treat religious clubs the same as other clubs like chess or drama?
Discussion Questions
- Should public school employees be able to express their religious beliefs at work, or does their role as government representatives change things?
- How can schools respect both religious freedom and the separation of church and state?
- Does it matter if participation in religious activity is truly voluntary, or can students still feel pressured?
Additional Resources
Go deeper with these resources