When, if ever, should the government be allowed to limit a person's constitutional rights in order to protect the community?
In other words: When should the government be able to take away someone's rights to keep other people safe?
This is the big question behind every case you'll study. The Constitution gives Americans certain rights, but sometimes those rights bump up against the safety or well-being of others. Each Supreme Court case explores where to draw that line. As you learn about these cases, think about how you would balance individual freedom with protecting the community.
Your Learning Path
Background Reading
Read the case background at your reading level
Argument Sorting
Sort legal arguments by which side they support
Debate Preparation
Rank arguments and prepare your position
Classroom Debate
Apply your understanding in structured debate
Featured Cases
Payton v. New York
Fourth Amendment rights and warrant requirements for home arrests
Explore Case →Available Reading Levels
Simplified Level
Simplified language, easy navigation
Standard Level
Grade-appropriate, detailed content